"Detroit sports fans should be reading 'Out of Bounds' pretty much every day" -- Rob Visconti, a.k.a. The Bleacher Guy
You can find out a lot while standing "Out of Bounds".
Opinions, observations, opines, obliqueness, oratories, and sarcastic humor (haven't found a word for sarcastic humor that starts with "o"), all about sports, with a decidedly Motor City flare. All that's missing from this blog are a bowl of pretzels and a cold one. Although, if you're buying....
Wednesday, March 18, 2009
Ford's Eulogy One For The PR Types
There's no riddle when it comes to the legacy of Davidson, Mr. D, who passed away last Friday at age 86. There's no need for a spin master or a cadre of P.R. types to punch up his bio and his legacy.
It's all there: championships; the resuscitation of a moribund franchise; a star-studded player roll; an entertainment empire that reaches beyond sports.
You don't have to be clubbed over the head to "get" why Davidson's legacy will land among the greatest of those in Detroit sports history.
I wonder what Bill Ford Sr. is thinking today.
It's ghoulish and morbid, but whenever one in a small clique passes, the other surviving members are looked at cross-eyed.
Ford is on the clock. So is Mike Ilitch -- in the legacy department. Unseemly, but true.
Ilitch is going to be 80 this summer, but by all accounts he seems to be in pretty good physical condition. Besides, he's a four-time Stanley Cup champ with the Red Wings, and a World Series participant with the Tigers. He's won enough to keep even the vermin-like fans among us from wishing his obituary to be printed.
But Ford? You don't want to know what they're wishing about his health. It's not very nice.
But that's what happens when you take a franchise and drive it into the muck, repeatedly, for 45 years.
Davidson, actually, was much like Ford -- in the beginning. He, too, emerged from a group of potential owners and bought out the syndicate so that he could run a team all by his lonesome. Davidson did it in 1974, ten years after Ford did it.
One of the folks who Ford bought out was Ralph Wilson, the longtime owner of the Buffalo Bills. Yeah, I know what you're thinking.
As I read of Davidson's funeral, and all of the A-list folks who attended and spoke on his behalf, it was hard not to think of what they might say about Ford, who turned 84 last Saturday, when it's his time.
What will the legacy be?
The sports broadcasting heads like to say, "If the playoffs started today..." as an excuse to talk, today, about things that are better talked about in the future -- like when they actually happen. So I'll borrow from that and say, "If Bill Ford's funeral was today..."
Morbid? Maybe. But it's a question worth asking: Just what WILL Ford's legacy be, should they lay him to rest before another pro football season is in the books?
Lemme see...
Well, I suppose they could speak of his integrity and his family's car company contributing greatly to the NFL's success in the 1960s and '70s, courtesy of advertising dollars. They could talk about how nice of a man he was. They could say that he wasn't a loud-mouthed buffoon, like so many of his contemporaries. They could talk about his loyalty to his employees and how he was, by what we've read and heard, simply wonderful to work for.
They will not, however, be able to say that he was a winner. Like Bill Davidson. Like Mike Ilitch. That part will have to be left out.
Ford's failure to field a championship-caliber football team won't, I maintain, determine the size of his funeral or the stature of folks who'll fly in for the event. He'll still draw the A-listers, mainly because of his longevity. The NFL will throw tons of bouquets at his memory. You really can't blame them; Ford has been, indeed, one of the league's classiest owners when it comes right down to it.
None of that nice guy, classy, loyal stuff means much to the hard-working, blue collar football fans in Detroit, however. And it's not like you can have one and not the other; we've seen how Davidson operated (and how Ilitch still does), and Mr. D was all those things that they'll say about Ford -- PLUS he was a winner. So it CAN be done.
It just wasn't done with the Lions, like it was done with the Pistons. Davidson took over a team that was in far worse shape than the Lions, in terms of fan support and tradition, bought out his partners, and went to work. He stumbled along the way (see Vitale, Dick) but then corrected himself in short order (see McCloskey, Jack). Davidson was bold, unwavering, and generous. Ford, sadly, has been only the last of those three.
I have no idea when the need will come to eulogize Bill Ford. I'm not one of those hoping for his demise. But time is running out to fashion a legacy of success that won't need to be camouflaged with flowery talk of how nice of a man he was.
All they had to do at Davidson's funeral was recite his resume. It'll take more than that to celebrate the Ford Ownership, when that time comes. A lot more.
Sunday, January 25, 2009
The Unknown Coach: Don't Fear Him, Necessarily
By a show of hands, how many of you heard of new Lions head coach Jim Schwartz prior to, say, Christmas Day?
I don’t see too many digits wagging. Let’s try by round of applause.
Hmm…awfully quiet in here, isn’t it?
Schwartz is the poor sap Lions management has tapped to transform its wretched football team into something that you can, at the very least, watch with both eyes open. That few people had ever heard of him prior to his name being bandied about in rumors after the season is inconsequential. He’s The Guy. So deal with it.
For the record, Schwartz was the defensive coordinator for the Tennessee Titans. Been that for the past eight seasons. By the numbers, Schwartz has coordinated some of the finest defenses in the NFL. Still, he did so largely in anonymity. Only the most diehard fans keep track of who the coordinators are for every team in the league.
Soon after the 2008 season ended – the Lions sans even one victory throughout the 16-game schedule – coach Rod Marinelli was canned. No surprise there. Then the names started being bandied about.
Schwartz’s kept rolling off the tongues of the so-called NFL “insiders”. The cape of anonymity was beginning to be ripped away from his back.
Defensive coordinator, Tennessee Titans. Even casual fans knew that the Titans have been known lately for having shutdown defenses.
2008 turned into 2009. Shaking off the fuzz of the New Year’s frivolities, more and more Lions fans became acutely aware of Jim Schwartz. He was going to be interviewed, in cloak and dagger fashion, somewhere in these United States.
Other names were mentioned as possible Lions coaches. But none more than Schwartz’s.
Then, on Monday the 12th, the Lions made Schwartz available for the media. He was in town for interview no. 2. This one was going to be with owner Bill Ford Sr. It was becoming more and more evident that this previously unknown assistant coach and little-known defensive coordinator was the Lions’ man. At the press gathering, Schwartz made a joke.
“I think,” he said of the Lions’ quarterback situation, “that it’s time to find a replacement for Bobby Layne.”
Schwartz displayed a key quality needed to coach the Lions: a wonderful sense of gallows humor.

Schwartz, prowling the sidelines as the Titans' Coordinator of Defense
Then, on Friday the 16th...
“I’m not here to exorcise ghosts of the past,” Schwartz, newly-hired as Lions head coach, said to the throng gathered at Ford Field. It was a nice sentiment, but someone should have broken the news to him: that’s exactly what he’s been brought to Detroit to do. Or else, why bother hiring a new coach at all?
Jim Schwartz has some credentials. He’s worked for a winning NFL program, in the upper level of coaching management. A coordinator position, if it was a beer, would be known as Head Coach Lite.
Don’t always fear the unknown.
In 1983, a well-coiffed gentleman stood before the Detroit media and posed with a basketball. He was dressed to the nines. We’d soon find out that, to Chuck Daly, “casual day” meant you left the hanky out of the pocket.

Chuck Daly: from unknown to Hall of Fame
Daly was unknown, largely. He had been a basketball coach out east, at the college level. He was an anonymous NBA assistant in Philadelphia. In between he gabbed into a radio microphone for a time, analyzing the Sixers games. Then, due to some unfortunate luck, Daly became interim coach of the Cleveland Cavaliers. It was a time when the team was derisively known as the Cadavers.
His record as an interim was 9-32.
And that was his career NBA coaching record when Pistons GM Jack McCloskey tried to sell Chuck Daly to the denizens in town as the answer to the team’s ongoing troubles. It was soon learned that Daly became the Pistons’ coach because a few bigger-named guys turned McCloskey down flat.
I can assure you that hardly anyone knew who the hell Chuck Daly was before he was unveiled to the media in May 1983. Then his resume was printed in the paper, and many of us wished we never met him at all. He appeared to be, at the time, just another sad sack coach breezing through town.
Today, when you walk into The Palace of Auburn Hills and look up, way up, you’ll see a banner with Chuck Daly’s name and symbolic “number” – 2 (for two NBA championships) – emblazoned on it.
The unknown coach hasn’t always worked out. To that, I must admit. And the Lions have had themselves plenty of those types.
Rick Forzano. Tommy Hudspeth. Marty Mornhinweg. Rod Marinelli. They were, after all was said and done, guys who were indeed just breezing through town.
So it’s forgivable and understandable for you to be wary of yet another low profile, no-name guy who’s been brought in to resuscitate pro football in Detroit. I don’t expect handstands and confetti because the Lions hired Jim Schwartz.
But Schwartz can coordinate himself some defense, and if there’s anything that was most slapstick about the Lions’ 0-16 season, it was the Swiss cheese defense they put on the field every Sunday. It was a defense bereft of playmakers, with pass defenders who played as if they were allergic to the football. It was, frankly, a joke.
Still, you’re given a free pass if you snicker and sneer at the hiring of the previously unknown Jim Schwartz. You do, after all, have history mostly on your side.
But what if Schwartz can coach a little bit, and sticks around for nine years or so, like Chuck Daly did with the Pistons?
It’s not like the Lions aren’t due or anything.
Friday, January 23, 2009
Cunningham and Schwartz: Mutual Admiration & Lions History Buffs, To Boot
So is any named Gunther.
The Lions' new defensive coordinator is both. Gunther Cunningham is thrilled to be in Detroit, working with old sidekick Jim Schwartz. He gushed over having the same philosophy as Schwartz (getting to the quarterback, being aggressive, playing limited zone defense) and talked about how the Lions roster, while holey, isn't a total loss.
Then he spoke to this old curmudgeon when he referenced Christiansen.
Seems Cunningham cut his coaching teeth in the 1970s, working for Christiansen at Stanford. Christiansen is a Hall of Fame defensive back, among the greatest Lions players of all time. And the reunion of Cunningham with Schwartz in Detroit (they worked together for three seasons in Tennessee) appears to have touched the 62-year-old's heart.
"Now you figure this one out," Cunningham told the Free Press. "I'm going to the Detroit Lions. Jack Christiansen is in the Hall of Fame and one of the greatest players the Lions ever had. Sometimes you really don't know what's in front of you.
"When my wife brought that up the other day, I had some tears in my eyes. Jack gave me an opportunity at Stanford when he was coaching, and I followed the Lions as a young man aspiring to play football. Now to go back to the place he played along with Jim Schwartz is really an emotional thing for me. Maybe this is the way it's all supposed to be."
Wow. Talk about playing the karma card.That's OK -- you don't see too many coaches come through here and start waxing philosophical about great Lions players from the Golden Age of pro football. Now already two have -- Schwartz and Cunningham. Schwartz made his "We need to find a replacement for Bobby Layne" crack when he met the media during the interview process.
So there's appreciation for the glorious history that used to be associated with the Lions, from the new head coach and the new coordinator of defense. That's a start.
But what's truly exciting about Cunningham, aside from the Christiansen mention, is the ferocity that's associated with him. An unnamed fellow NFL coach said Cunningham is "half crazy." Schwartz said that, in Cunningham's world, "It's always fourth and one." And Cunningham himself said, "Whether a player likes me doesn't really matter to me. As long as I have his respect."
All of that should be music to a Lions fan's ears.
Words are just that, I know. But when was the last time you heard an incoming Lions coach -- head coach, position coach, coordinator -- described as "half crazy", in a GOOD way?
I liked Cunningham's remark about not caring whether his players like him or not. There's a lot of Scotty Bowman in there, and that's not a bad thing.
The Lions have tried the mad man before. He was Mike Martz, the high-maintenance offensive coordinator. But Martz wasn't half crazy, he was simply crazy. And totally unwilling to bend. Cunningham spoke of how he played zone defense in Kansas City, because that's what head coach Herman Edwards wanted -- even though zone flies in the face of what Cunningham's all about. You think Martz would defer like that to his head coach?
I have no clue how much better the Lions defense will be next season under the Mutual Admiration Society members Jim Schwartz and Gunther Cunningham. But both of them seem to appreciate where this franchise has been -- lo those many years ago -- and where it deserves to be, once more. And I'm not so sure that their predecessors have always "gotten" that.
Monday, January 19, 2009
Once-Blind Cardinals Finally Find Their Nut
Another one of the league's ugly ducklings finally made its transformation to swan. It only took them six decades, but they did it.
The Lions, by that measure, have ten years still to go. But there IS hope.
The Arizona Cardinals are going to the Super Bowl. In uniform and everything; I don't mean as guests of the league in a private suite. They're one of the last anomalies of nature: somehow, their metabolism slowed and came to a halt.
There is now one less member of the Never Been To The Super Bowl Club.
Sitting at the table now are the Cleveland Browns, New Orleans Saints, Jacksonville Jaguars, Houston Texans. Oh, and the Lions. In fact, the Lions are at the head of the table. They're the chairmen of this board.
The Lions supplant the Cardinals now at the head -- of the table, that is.
The Cardinals captured the NFC Championship yesterday, their first title of any kind since 1947. They did it with their third straight playoff win, all achieved against conventional thinking. The surprising Atlanta Falcons were supposed to run around, over, and through them. The Carolina Panthers, at home, were supposed to make mincemeat of the desert team who weren't supposed to be able to win games played in the Eastern time zone. And the Philadelphia Eagles, battle-tested and used to these sort of situations, were supposed to put an end to this Cardinal Mania, for goodness sake.
None of that happened. The Lions are now, officially, by fact, numbers and irrefutable evidence, the most dysfunctional team in the NFL.
The Cardinals used to be that team. Their drought since 1947 was liberally sprinkled with slapstick and foolishness. The owners are the Bidwill family, and that was once as knee-slapping as the Ford ownership in Detroit. The Cardinals tried Chicago, then St. Louis, then Arizona. They tried calling themselves the Phoenix Cardinals for a while, before deciding to indict the entire state.
Their players used to race to the bank, to cash their paychecks, before they bounced. This was the 1950s days of the Chicago Cardinals. They once hired Bud Wilkinson as coach, some 15 years after he coached his last game -- in college. Their once-promising quarterback, Neil Lomax, broke his leg and was never the same. They had a player die in training camp of heat exhaustion (JV Cain). They would wear white jerseys at home against the Dallas Cowboys, forcing the 'Boys to wear blue -- thinking that the dark tops would function as the Cowboys' Kryptonite. Their leading pass receiver was regularly a running back (Larry Centers). They tried Buddy Ryan as coach. Now THERE was some Kryptonite. They lined up against Barry Sanders, who was playing his first game in nine months, without any practice, and gave up a 17-yard run on his first carry.
They have been the league's vagabonds, nudged out of two cities and a few time zones along the way.
But, the Bidwills have been a constant -- the common denominator. Just like the Fords in Detroit.
So what did the Cardinals do right?
Well, they caught lightning in a bottle, which happens from time to time in the NFL. But beyond that, they made some shrewd personnel moves, and had some draft success.
I know, I know -- that's like saying Charlie Brown has a chance, too, if only he'd pick a different holder for his placekicks. And Bill Ford is the Lions' Lucy Van Pelt.
But that's what happened: acquisitions of Kurt Warner, Edgerrin James. The drafting of Larry Fitzgerald. And others. And that all-important intangible: getting hot at the right time.
The Cardinals, to be fair and square, were not a great football team all season long. In fact, they were downright awful at times. They might even have had trouble beating the Lions on some weeks. They went into the playoffs as arguably the least attractive girl at the dance.
Now they'll be boogeying with the Pittsburgh Steelers.
There was a time when the Steelers were ragtag and the Keystone Kops of the NFL. Many of the youngens can't fathom that; to them, the Steelers have always been good -- strong championship contenders. But throughout much of their existence -- from the late-1920s to the early-1970s -- the Steelers were almost as comical as the Cardinals. Owner Art Rooney, thank goodness, lived long enough to see his team finally win the Big One in 1975.
The Cardinals and the Steelers, for the whole enchilada. Likely not a popular choice in Las Vegas back in September.
Then again, despite as bad as the Lions have been, how many thought they'd pull off the imperfection of 0-16?
It's tempting and maybe even comforting to say that, if the Bidwills can make it to the Super Bowl, just about anyone can.
That's pretty much what we're down to in Detroit: living vicariously through other franchises.
Friday, January 16, 2009
Schwartz Has More To Offer Than Just A Non-M Last Name
Jim Schwartz is the latest one to sign his own walking papers. That's what you do, you know, when you sign on to be a head coach in pro sports. The clock starts ticking toward your eventual ziggy before the ink dries on your signature.
But that's just so cynical of me, isn't it?
First impressions of Schwartz, introduced today as the Lions' new head coach: not bad. He sounded confident and relaxed. Like this wasn't his first head coaching job. Like he wasn't stepping into the doo-doo of 0-16 and a dysfunctional front office. Like he's done this sort of thing before.
I didn't get that impression with Schwartz's predecessor, the beleaguered Rod Marinelli. From the get go, although I liked Marinelli's military-like persona, Marinelli spoke like he was, well, doing this for the first time. His speech seemed too contrived, too prepared. I didn't draw the comparison until I heard Schwartz talk, and he was very relaxed and "oh, by the way."
Of course, Schwartz has been a defensive coordinator for some eight years. You'd expect him to be more polished, frankly. And he sure seems to be.
He even got off a crack.
"If I had known it was going to be this cold here, I would have asked for more money," he said as the media types laughed.
Hey, if he knew what he was getting himself into, truly knew, he'd ask for a Brinks Truck.
The Lions must have listened to me, for a change.
I implored them to find someone who comes from a winning pedigree, and at the very least from a coordinator's role. Well, Schwartz would seem to qualify; he learned from Bill Belichick early on, and Jeff Fisher later. He coordinated the Tennessee Titans defense, and did alright. The Titans' defense was consistently among the best in the NFL. So that's good.
It remains to be seen, of course, how Schwartz will react once it sinks in: that he doesn't appear to have as much say-so in personnel matters as many NFL head coaches possess. Also, once it sinks in that tweedle-dee and tweedle-dum, aka Martin Mayhew and Tom Lewand, are really the ones in charge. Hopefully, Schwartz won't become mystified. Check back come draft time.

The Lions' new head coach, Jim Schwartz, in happier days
But for now, it's all about Schwartz hiring a staff and beginning to evaluate what he has in Detroit. It's not much, and he said as much on Monday, when he was propped up before the media as part of his interviewing process. He politely said there were "some holes" in the roster, but was quick to add that many teams have such holes. That wasn't an easy thing to buy.
When the Lions hired Steve Mariucci, some six years ago already, they created a humongous stage on Ford Field's turf and Mooch made the long walk from the tunnel, flanked by Matt Millen and Bill Ford Jr. Even Mariucci himself, once he saw what the Lions had created, spectacle-wise, said simply, "Wow."
Too bad Mooch never lived up to that stage.
This time, Jim Schwartz held a simple, rather brief gathering -- in the same spot where Lions coaches speak to the media every week. His demeanor was casual, belying the gravity of the moment. He talked of his growing up as one of nine kids in Baltimore. Not exactly a hard-scrabble life, but certainly not with a silver spoon in his mouth, either. He said his dad would have been disappointed in him if he didn't take this challenge, because the Schwartzes never shrink from challenges. He talked a little about making his defense all-purpose: able to quell the run and the pass, if need be, based on the opponent. He spoke of becoming big and strong on the football field.
Then, just like that, he was pulled away, after a few innocent questions.
But that's OK. All intro press conferences of coaches are alike, mostly. But I was still taken by Schwartz's casualness, and his lack of awe. He expected to be a head coach someday, and now it's here. 0-16 doesn't faze him. We see a gooey, hideous mess. He simply sees a challenge.
The grass on the Lions' side of the fence never looks as brown and as full of manure as we see it from the inside.
So good luck to Mr. Schwartz. For the record, I'm OK with this.
His last name doesn't begin with M, for one.
It's a start.
Wednesday, January 07, 2009
Lions' Ugly Betty Coaching Job Could Be An America Ferrera
The Lions' coaching job, under the right circumstances, is like America Ferrera: out of makeup, it's pleasant to look at. But the Lions are making it into America's alter ego, Ugly Betty.
This is what the Lions have to offer, before they uglied it up: a ravenous fan base; lots of salary cap money; excellent team facilities; nowhere to go but up; the opportunity to write a job ticket for life, in Detroit or elsewhere, if successful.
Here's what the Ugly Betty version is: a wretched roster with little say in its makeup; no big-time money; a front office with 0-16 odors all over it who is resistant to hiring a bona fide football guy.
The Lions are going for coaching on the cheap again.
They are taking their seat at the NFL's poker table with laughably fewer chips than their colleagues who are also in search of a new head coach.
They're setting themselves up for another Marty Mornhinweg or Rod Marinelli disaster -- aka hiring a guy who wants to be a head coach in the NFL in the worst way. Well, that's what you would be, in Detroit, under these circumstances: a head coach in the worst way.
It apparently isn't ugly enough that the roster is severely talent challenged. Not ugly enough that the personnel input is apparently not going to be there in full force. Not ugly enough that the new guy has to work under what will be a three-man committee, two of whom are part of a regime that has orchestrated a 31-97 record (4-12 avg.) since 2001.
The sad thing is, the Lions' coaching job could be very much America Ferrera and not Ugly Betty.
Money. Authority. Control. The Big Three as far as NFL head coaches are concerned. Ironic that a team whose city is synonymous with the Big Three automakers can't come close to offering the Big Three to its next head coach.
The Lions keep getting it wrong.

The Lions' head coaching job (left) as it could be; the way they're portraying it (right)
They gave Monte Clark the fancy title of Head Coach and Director of Football Operations in 1978, but GM Russ Thomas was still around, and so that title was largely a snow job on Monte. As long as Thomas, a close friend of Bill Ford Sr., was still in the Lions' employ, there wasn't going to be TRUE power for the coach.
They gave Bobby Ross some power, but his players confounded him. He committed a self-ziggy in 2000, and if you read anything about Bobby, you'll find out that he considered doing the same thing at San Diego and, before that, at Georgia Tech. He quit at Army, too. Bobby tends to get flustered and want to vamoose. But the Lions apparently either didn't know that or didn't care when they hired him in 1997.
Before and in between there's been a lot of hiring on the cheap: Rick Forzano, Tommy Hudspeth, Mornhinweg, Marinelli. They threw a lot of dough at Steve Mariucci, but did little to no due diligence on Mooch, either.
If reports are true that the Lions are interested in Stanford coach Jim Harbaugh, then the situation becomes even more slapstick. You can count on one hand how many college coaches have successfully made the transition to the NFL, and you'd have at least one middle finger left over.
The Lions are trying to do this major, major reclamation project in the same manner that a man shows up to a gun battle with a knife. And they're setting themselves up to slicing their own throats. Again.
Tuesday, December 30, 2008
Marinelli Gets The Ziggy, But Ford Didn't Fire Him
Ford didn't fire Marinelli; circumstances did. Ford was merely the vessel, the one who sent out the press release announcing the development, one that even he, with his loyal and kind heart, couldn't stall.
There are so few things you can count on in life anymore: getting stuck in traffic when you're running late; being the one who finishes the toilet paper roll; paying taxes; dying. Oh, and this one: going 0-16 will get you fired.
It wasn't impressive, not at all, that Marinelli got the ziggy yesterday after 0-16 and 1-23 and 10-38. The zenith of his time here was when he was 9-15 after the 6-2 start of 2007 (remember that?). Actually, the zenith of his time here, I believe, was in January 2006 -- when he stood in front of the media throng the day he was announced as head coach.
"Good morning, men," Marinelli famously said that day, as if he was a military general addressing the troops. I loved that opening. And I was fooled, as I've been in the past, that the Lions had finally found the right man to coach.
I liked that Marinelli was a D-line man, and that he appeared to appreciate the work done in the trenches. He seemed like substance over style. Then he went out and hired the run-and-gun Mike Martz to coordinate the offense, and that kind of flew in the face of the substance over style thing.
The last Lions head coach worth a hill of beans was Joe Schmidt, and if he hadn't gotten so disgusted with GM Russ Thomas and quit, Schmidt would have been the coach here for as long as he wanted. He was a former Lions player, maybe among the Top Five in team history, and Ford would have been loyal to him. Sadly, Ford sided with Thomas in the power struggle, and the Lions lost out on the best coach they've had since George Wilson and Buddy Parker.
But that's all in the past. It's all about looking forward, but with Ford in the driver's seat, you don't get a chance to look very far. His myopic thinking and approach has choked this franchise, and what you saw with 0-16 was the culmination of a perfect storm of poor management, bad personnel decisions, and all the bad chickens coming home to roost.
Yesterday, I asked for calm, to see what Ford would do in the Allen Park offices in the wake of 0-16. I had not posted those thoughts for more than a minute when the word came down that the only real move was to can the coach, which was terribly predictable and a cause-and-effect of going winless. Oh, another personnel guy is due to be hired, but he will, apparently, be nothing more than part of a three-headed monster -- two of which are coated with the stench of what's been going on with the Lions since 2001.
Rod Marinelli wasn't ready to be a head coach. As I've said before, there's no crime in that. There's nothing wrong with being a fine position coach. Those are necessary, too. But he was a Matt Millen hire, who made three bad coaching choices. He was infatuated with Marty Mornhinweg after one late-night film session; he didn't do the proper due diligence on Steve Mariucci to see if he would be a good fit here; and he selected Marinelli based on a gut feeling, since the resume wasn't there. So don't blame Coach Rod. HE didn't hire him, after all.
So Millen is gone, but the feeling of euphoria that his ziggying was supposed to bring never really materialized. There's a sort of "out of the frying pan and into the fire" thing going on here. Or, "be careful what you wish for." Folks wanted to roll the dice and take their chances with the canning of Millen. Then as the losses piled up this season, they decided to take their chances with a winless year.
The fans got craps for their trouble and risk.
Happy New Year.
Monday, December 29, 2008
Biggest Mistake Lions Can Make Is Being Paralyzed By History
You can literally say that it's easier to go 16-0 in the NFL than 0-16, because the Lions pulled off the latter one year after the New England Patriots accomplished the former.
0-16. Put it in there with 714, 56, 17-0, .406, 72-10, and any other famous sports number that you can think of. They'll be talking about this one for years, decades probably.
The Tampa Bay Bucs aren't off the hook yet, though. Remember, they lost their first 26 games before winning. The Lions have "only" lost 17 straight. So come on back sometime next late-October and see how that's shaping up.
The Lions went winless. For an entire season. In today's NFL, built on parity and designed to reward blind squirrels on occasion. Flip through the records since the NFL-AFL merger of 1970. You'll find that even the most wretched teams win two, maybe three games. Some indeed have only won one. But they did win.
So where were you when it happened? Do you remember what you were wearing, who you were with, what you were doing, when the final seconds ticked off the clock in Green Bay yesterday? Chances are that you still will, ten, twenty years from now. It's the Kennedy Assassination moment of the NFL. It's a story that you will retell, to your grandkids, and any other wide-eyed person who wasn't old enough to remember this.
But you know what? Who cares?
There's nothing anyone can do about it now. 0-16 is there, and always will be. But next year is another season. Look at the Miami Dolphins: 1-15 in 2007, divisional champs in 2008.
The Lions' biggest mistake won't be that they went 0-16. It'll be if they get paralyzed by history, and assume a deer-in-the-headlights mentality.
Pick yourself up off the road before you get run over again.
That's why this off-season will be the most critical in the team's history. The legacy of Bill Ford Sr. and his football franchise won't be that they managed to finish an entire season sans a victory. It will be, What did they do about it? How did they react? What happened after they bottomed out?
I don't think too many of the Lions fans will care about 0-16 if the team pulls itself up and gets serious about making sure nothing remotely like this ever happens again. It'll start with the hiring of a new football man, obviously. And a new coach. In that order. The drumbeat for Bill Parcells has already begun, in the wake of the news that Parcells can become a "free agent" upon the completion of the sale of the Miami Dolphins; the Big Tuna can walk after such a development.
But whether it's Parcells -- and nothing would wash away the muck of 0-16 like that kind of news -- or someone else, it'll be the first step in the healing process.

Congress isn't an option, but SOMEONE'S gotta fix this mess
I know, I know -- this is Old Man Ford we're talking about. The guy who implied that no Earth-shattering changes were headed the Lions' way.
Don't be so sure.
Those infamous comments, spoken before the Lions' game with the Saints a week ago Sunday, caused a furor, and I can understand that. But at that point, 0-16 was still not a reality, though it appeared to be a certainty.
Things sometimes change when the cold, harsh reality sets in.
Not even Ford can shrug off 0-16. I know many of you won't agree with me when you read that, but it's what I believe. If Parcells indeed opts out of his Miami deal, he just might receive a call from Ford. I know you might not agree with that, either, but again, my opinion. And the Parcells news hadn't been reported when Ford made his comments to Tom Kowalski on Dec. 21.
All I'm saying is, let's wait and see what the Lions do in the coming weeks, for THAT will be the time to start writing the legacy of the 2008 season.
When you seemingly can't get any worse -- and that's what 0-16 screams -- then what are you gonna do about it?
Ford hasn't been unequivocally the worst, factually, until now. Let's see what the old guy does in reaction.
Monday, December 15, 2008
What Else To Say About Lions -- Especially When You Don't Watch The Game?
What, did the Colts all have one hand tied behind their backs?
I didn't watch this one. Correction: I saw the Colts' opening drive -- the expected hot knife-thru-butter, 78-yard affair that ate up half of the first quarter. Then I saw the Lions' cold-butter-on-bread, three-and-out struggle, then I saw the Colts muff the ensuing punt. Then the TV got switched off and it was time to head out for a school affair with our daughter and the grandmoms. The DVR was used, but I doubt I'll watch it. The game only got recorded because the last thing I would have wanted to happen was to come home and find out that the Lions pulled off a miraculous upset and I had no evidence to confirm it. So I'm sure the game will fall victim to the "delete" button soon.
No need to write much about the loss. It's no. 14 on the way to the infamous Sweet Sixteen. Another game in which the Lions' opponents sandbagged their way through much of it, only ratcheting it up when absolutely necessary. They really almost can beat the Lions with one hand tied behind their backs.
Yet it would be soooo typical if the Lions went into Green Bay at 0-15, and fouled everything up by beating the mediocre Packers, simultaneously avoiding 0-16 and snapping their 0-17 streak in Wisconsin. I don't know what to say about it except that there would be all sorts of irony in there, among the muck of this season.
But this winless campaign sets up maybe the most interesting off-season in franchise history. Never before has owner Bill Ford Sr. had his hand forced with the coaching situation. Head coach Rod Marinelli isn't going to be fired by Ford -- he's going to be fired by circumstances. 0-16 gets the coach fired, even in Detroit -- to answer Darryl Rogers' legendary question about what it takes to get the ziggy. So Ford will have no choice but to broom Marinelli, asking him to pack up his rock and his shovel and take his thoughts about invisibility with him. That much is certain. But what's not so certain is who the next administration will be. I can't wait for the hot stove league to fire up.
Meanwhile, get a good look at this bunch, because you're not likely to see more than a handful of them ever again. I reckon that as many as 20-25 of the current Lions will be released into the private sector before next football season, joining the rest of us stiffs who are trying to earn a dollar. Maybe half of the remaining 30 or so players will wind up as backups elsewhere or on some team's practice squad, and the other half might stick around, temporarily. Like I said before, I'd keep Calvin Johnson, Jason Hanson, and take my chances with 51 rookies, free agents, and the like.
It's getting boring writing about the Lions. This is the time of the year where you run out of things to say about all the losing. But at least there's the historical implications that two more losses -- just two more! -- will bring. That'll liven things up a bit, at least.
Quarterback Dan Orlovsky says there are 15 plays out there that happened this year that, had they gone the Lions' way, would have transformed them into a .500 team. I'm serious. He really said that after yesterday's game. It's a nice sentiment, but as was pointed out, the Lions don't have the requisite talent or skill to have turned those 15 mysterious plays in their favor -- and that's why those plays, whatever they were, went against them. He may as well have said, "If only we had better players, we would be a .500 team." At least he would have been spot on in his assessment. Instead, he just looks like a boob -- just like his head coach.
I don't know what Marinelli said to Colts' coach and longtime friend Tony Dungy after the game, but I hope some of it included, "Hey -- if you need a d-line coach next season, ring me."
Don't recent former Lions head coaches seem to land on their feet? Marty Mornhinweg with the Philadelphia Eagles, Steve Mariucci with the NFL Network. Dick Jauron with the Buffalo Bills. Hey, even Bobby Ross ended up with Army. Come to think of it, Marinelli is a military man. It's food for thought.
Monday, November 24, 2008
Lions Are Not Only Winless On The Field, But Losers In Their Minds
Knowing he had to trade Lanier, McCloskey then got an idea. A BIG idea.
"I looked at the team as an expansion team," McCloskey told me in an interview many years ago. "We were really an expansion team."
Ex-coach Dick Vitale stripped the Pistons bare of draft picks, thanks to bad trades -- one of which was McAdoo. The team was lucky to win one of every four games. So McCloskey picked up the phone and called his old friend and boss, Lakers GM Jerry West.
"I thought that if we could get Magic, that would have been great," Trader Jack said about Lakers rookie Magic Johnson.
So McCloskey asked West if he was sitting down.
"Then I told him that he could have every player on my roster for Magic," McCloskey said, chuckling.
EVERY player?
"Every player. We would have taken Magic, signed a bunch of free agents and CBA players, and built from there," McCloskey said.
West ran the outrageous offer past Lakers ownership, but it was rejected.
"But they were thinking about it," McCloskey said with a grin.
It's tempting to say that the Lions, today, might want to take a look at Project Magic that Jack McCloskey put forth in early 1980.
Tempting to want to walk into the locker room and rip every single name plate off the stalls, save perhaps Calvin Johnson's. And Jason Hanson's.
Keep Calvin and Hanson, and find 51 other players, and go from there.
You think I'm joking?
What's happening with the Lions now isn't just a talent chasm between them and the rest of the NFL. That's well known and hard enough to overcome. What's also going down is a mentality, deep and ingrained. The thought, indeed even the belief, that it's never going to happen here -- from among the players themselves.
The Lions monkeyed around and found themselves with a nifty little 17-0 lead after the first quarter yesterday against Tampa Bay. They were making plays, on both sides of the ball. The Bucs, no doubt, were a little nauseous, wondering if they'd be the first team to lose to the Lions this season.
No worries. There were still 45 minutes left to play, after all!
The Lions imploded, and lost, 38-20. If this was basketball, we'd say that the Bucs closed the game with a 38-3 run.
But beyond that, some of the Lions players started using words like "here we go again" and "we don't know how to win." Doesn't matter who said it; but it was said, and more than once.
It's clear: the Lions players may talk about being embarrassed and being angry and determined, but not only are they outclassed, talent-wise, they are beaten mentally before the ball is even kicked off.
So it's not enough, anymore, to bring a player in, here and there, to address needs. The Brian Kellys and Leigh Boddens aren't enough.
There's been a lot of talk about "blowing it up", and starting over. Much of that talk has come here, in the form of the Eno Plan. But the talk has primarily revolved around the front office and coaching situation. The personnel part of it has been brushed aside, probably because it seems too daunting right now. It's a lot easier to change a few heads than 53.
But we gotta keep thinking big here. What would be wrong, really, with a super duper serious turnover in personnel? Something huge, like 60 percent or more?
Think of it: 30+ players wearing Lions uniforms in 2009 that aren't doing so right now. More, if you can do it. The more new faces you get in here, the more players you have that look at you cross-eyed when you start talking about recent history of Detroit football, the better. The more who will pin a pencil-necked sportswriter against the wall and sneer, "I don't know what you're talking about when you say 'losing mentality.' I'm a winner and I don't think like that," the better.
The Lions need a mental enema.
You can't do it with this current bunch, because these guys have no idea what it's like to handle any degree of success -- not even a good first quarter, for cripes sakes. Even a new GM, a new coach, isn't going to be enough with the current roster. Because a lot of these Lions have been through that before, too -- at least the new coach part. They've seen and heard the brave words of the new man at the helm. They've been told that the bar is high and the West Coast offense is the way to the Promised Land and to pound the rock and dig for the light. And still they know, deep down, that they will come out at the wrong end of the score at the final gun every Sunday.
The 2009 Lions must be drastically different from the 2008 version -- and not just with the guys who wear suits and ties and whistles around their necks. The dudes in pads have to be broomed, too. McCloskey only had to try to unload 12 players with the Pistons; the Lions must somehow jettison 30 or 40. But they simply have to try. This is one case where change for change's sake is warranted. You know how many men are out there dying for a chance to play pro football? Guys who were maybe the last cuts in other training camps, or those looking for that "big break"? Guys with a pristine, blank memory when it comes to Lions football.
Think of it as throwing away your virus-infested computer with a fresh new one.
The Lions are not only beaten on the football field, they are beaten between the ears. The latter must be corrected before you can see any improvement on the former.
Monday, November 17, 2008
Marinelli Has Already Channeled Bobby Ross, So Why Not Joe Schmidt, Too?
I'm recalling it because Lions head coach Rod Marinelli had some frustrated words for the media after yesterday's 31-22 loss to the Carolina Panthers, and the words were hauntingly familiar to the mini-diatribe that Lions HC Schmidt had against Ackerman, way back in the early-1970s.
Ackerman was haranguing Schmidt -- Al did that a lot to the coaches and players in his prime -- about the Lions' linebacker situation in training camp at Cranbrook. And Al had finally gotten under Schmidt's skin (another frequent occurrence) when the exchange broke into something similar to the following.
Al: Do you feel comfortable with the linebackers you have right now? You seem to be a little thin at linebacker.
Schmidt: What are you saying, Al?
Al: I'm saying that it seems like you're a little thin at linebacker.
Schmidt: You want to find me one, Al? You have a linebacker you'd like me to play?
Al: But--
Schmidt: Where am I going to find a linebacker, Al? You gonna find me a linebacker?
You gotta love it.
Marinelli came perilously close to reenacting that "discussion" after the game Sunday. He was trying to explain his team's 17th loss in its last 18 games, which brought his record to 10-32 as Lions coach. The issue, in Marinelli's mind, seemed to be talent, if you glean something from his choice of words, which were very Joe Schmidt-like.
"There's nobody else out there," Marinelli said. "There's nobody out there. You want to go out on the street and look for me? If you bring somebody back, I'll look at him. No, no. You go out on the street and find one. So these are the men I have."
Now, I would never expect a football coach to admit that his team isn't talented enough -- at least not on the record. That's expecting a little too much honesty. Besides, that's what the media and the bottom-feeding bloggers are for, he wrote, being a member of both camps.
But these may also have been the smartest words to come out of Marinelli's mouth in a very long time. Of course, it's all for naught. He's to be fired moments after the final whistle this season. Make no mistake.
Rather, the Lions better make no mistake.
There's going to be, maybe, quite an off-season around Detroit when it comes to its pro football team. Team president Matt Millen has been fired, and he needs to be replaced. Interim GM Martin Mayhew may be one of the brightest young executives around, but it hardly matters.
Here's the deal: the Lions have no face. They generate no excitement. They are hemorrhaging fans. They're like the Republicans, for gosh sakes.
But they have two chances to make one, just like the old NBA free throw system. They have two vacancies to fill: permanent GM, and head coach. They need only to get one right to start shoring up their fan base.
If they stick with Mayhew (which would be a mistake, but that's a whole other blog post) then the Lions had better snare a high-profile head coach with success sprinkled all over his resume. No more position coaches or "highly regarded" coordinators. But if the new GM is high profile and has credibility, then he might be able to pass the smell test if he were to hire a lesser-known guy as head coach. That's because the fans would be listening to the new GM, not the old administration, tell them why the new coach is going to be just terrific.
There are columnists and colleagues of mine, who I respect, who'll tell you that they've never called for a man to be fired and they never will. Fine. But what about accountability? Shouldn't that be demanded?
Rod Marinelli, if he finishes the expected 1-15 or 0-16 this season, will be either 11-37 or 10-38 as Lions head coach. You cannot -- can NOT -- have such a record after three seasons and not be held accountable, i.e. fired. At least, you can't if your bosses are serious about running a business.
Bill Ford Sr. didn't make his money in pro football. He made it in the auto industry. Luckily for him, football isn't his main source of income. Of course, the whole auto industry thing isn't looking too good lately, either. Regardless, the Fords are businessmen, first and foremost. And I would hope that the businessman in them would recognize that you can't bring back both halves of this current GM/coach partnership in 2009. It would be a disaster, from public relations to customer service.
How many season ticket holders have the Lions lost in recent years? And how many more would they lose if they try to come back in 2009 with Martin Mayhew as GM and Rod Marinelli as head coach?
No, one of them, at least, must be replaced -- and for sure it must be Marinelli. To be 11-37 or 10-38 and still be on the job is heinous. I've written it before: everywhere else in pro sports, if you lose you get fired. Why shouldn't it be true in Detroit with the Lions?
And to my compadres who get icky over calling for a coach's head: there are only 32 men in the world who hold the title of head coach in the National Football League. So shouldn't these 32 men be the best of the best? And if they're not, shouldn't someone else get a shot at being one of those elite 32?
Marinelli, it appears, is at his wit's end. He doesn't have the guys to compete for sixty minutes in the NFL. So it should be the players who go, right? Perhaps, but in Miami, where the talent isn't all that different this year than from 2007, the Dolphins are 6-4 one year after being 1-15. They changed coaches, in case you didn't know. Now look at them. So maybe the Lions don't have the talent to compete for sixty minutes with this head coach. Oh, and they changed presidents too, to a guy named Bill Parcells.
The problem isn't just talent. Marinelli is in over his head, from clock management to game planning to in-game decisions. That's no crime; maybe he's better suited to be a position coach. That's not against the law, last I checked.
So don't tell me that turnarounds are impossible, or that the fix can't be quick. Not if you make the right hires -- and dismissals.
Monday, October 27, 2008
Lions, Bengals Should Decide #1 Overall Draft Pick The Manly Way
The line was: "That's just crazy enough to work!"
Oh, you can still see it pop up from time to time. Sometimes I even like saying it; I've had a pretty good success rate of getting laughs when it spills off my lips.
As I was sitting here, trying to figure out what to write about another Lions loss -- this time without the, ahem, benefit of having actually seen the game -- the idea came to me out of the blue.
The Lions are 0-7. The Cincinnati Bengals are 0-8. They would appear to be on a crash course to see who will get the #1 overall pick in next year's draft, especially since they don't play each other. It's still highly likely that they will end up with identical records, be it 0-16, 1-15 or something.
So here's the idea. Instead of using some silly little coin flip or sucking ping pong balls through a vacuum and into a rotating cylinder -- or any other supposedly "random" little trick that you can come up with -- in order to determine overall pick #1, why not hold the first annual Toilet Bowl?
You heard me.
As part punishment, part fairness, part grotesque sadism, make the Lions and Bengals suit up the week between the conference championships and the Super Bowl, pitting them against each other in the Toilet Bowl. At stake? The 2009 #1 Draft Pick. The winner of the game gets the #1 pick. And, to make things interesting (for what is the real difference between #1 and #2, anyway?), the loser of the Toilet Bowl gets bumped all the way down to the 32nd pick. I know, tough cookies for the loser, but maybe, just maybe, you might get a decent football game if you frame it this way.
I'm only partly kidding, by the way. What scares me is that I wonder if I'm really kidding at all.
I haven't seen much of the Bengals this season, even with my NFL Sunday Ticket package. Just because you CAN watch the Bengals doesn't mean that you DO. I'm sure they're saying the same thing about the Lions in Cincinnati. But a look at the standings shows the Bengals with 104 points scored and 217 points allowed; the Lions are at 114-212. Verrrry similar.
Now, it may not be what Lions RB Rudi Johnson had in mind when he signed with the Lions after several years with the Bengals, but there you have it.
Here's this week's incredible Lions statistic: Washington QB Jason Campbell, Sunday, became the sixth quarterback out of the seven the Lions have played this season to register a career high in QB rating. SIX OUT OF SEVEN! The exception? Minnesota's Gus Frerotte, who surely would contemplate retirement immediately if you were to show him this nugget of info.
But it's true. Matt Ryan, Aaron Rodgers, J.T. O'Sullivan, Kyle Orton, Matt Schaub, and Campbell have all had career days, literally, against the Lions this season. Even for a winless team, even for a team with the Lions pedigree, that's mind-boggling.
But it's not funny. It's not cute, even if we pretend it to be. It's shameful, is what it is. It's embarrassing and humiliating and disgusting, is what it is. It's being the league's punching bag, its fire hydrant for all the dogs.
Ahh, but would the Lions be the punching bag and fire hydrant for the Bengals, too?
Let's strap it on the last week of January and find out.
It's just crazy enough to work!
Monday, October 13, 2008
Zebras' Errors Might Have Actually Mattered To Most Any Other Team Than The Lions
The Lions, as you've read all over the Internet and in those things that preceded it called newspapers, got jobbed yesterday in Minnesota by the zebras. Twice. And on one of those occasions, the very vehicle that was designed to prevent such malfeasance upheld the mistake that was made on the field.
Why, it might have actually been a travesty, if the Lions were any sort of a football team.
Whether they won in the Metrodome or not -- and isn't it just par for the course that the Vikings thieved another one away from the Lions -- wouldn't have changed, one iota, what happens to the Lions after this season is safely in the books. And if you're looking for evidence that confirms the suspicion that 0-4 teams are treated more shabbily than others, look no further than yesterday's game. So Lions fans' outrage is probably justified, but as I wrote last week, is also just more wasted negative energy.
There's no real difference between 1-4 and 0-5, is there?
Bad Call No. 1 was the opinion on the field, and upheld in that supposedly just court of appeals in the replay booth, that WR Calvin Johnson fumbled after a key, long pass reception in the fourth quarter. It was one of those calls that you feel better about once you see the video evidence play out on the TV screen.
"Oh, that will be overturned. No sweat," you say as you venture to the fridge for another pop.
Then you return to the television and see that the court of appeals must be crooked, on the take, or with money on the Vikings. Or all of the above. For the call was confirmed, even though it sure looked like that Johnson had control of the ball when his knee made contact with the turf.

The referee explained afterward that there was no irrefutable evidence that the call on the field was wrong, so he had no choice but to uphold it. Maybe they showed him Tom and Jerry reruns under the hood instead of the actual play. Because had they shown him what we were privy to in the comforts of our own homes and neighborhood bars, then he certainly would have reversed the call.
Bad Call no. 2 was the real killer, though. The phantom pass interference collared on Leigh Bodden -- who played wonderfully -- late in the fourth quarter that instantly put the Vikings in game-winning field goal range. Not only did Bodden appear to play the pass perfectly with minimal contact, there was a question as to whether the ball was catchable at all. Earlier in the game, the officials let Johnson get mugged but kept the hankies in their pockets, apparently reasoning that Johnson could never have caught a long bomb near the end zone.
Bodden demanded an apology from the NFL, then quickly admitted that such a gesture wouldn't change a darn thing; Lions lose, whether the league is sorry or not. But they probably aren't; who cares about 0-5, 31-86 teams?
Then there's the old adage of, "Well, if we did some things better, those calls wouldn't matter."
Bull-oney.
The Lions rushed the passer. They blocked a field goal attempt. They were decent against the run. They broke off a 50-yard run of their own. They didn't really turn the ball over. They forced two fumbles from Adrian Peterson. They tackled. For long stretches of time, they looked like a pro football team. Yet it wasn't quite good enough.
At one point, with the Lions threatening to not get blown out for the first time this season, Fox's Ron Pitts wondered whether the action on the field was a result of the Lions raising their game a level, or the Vikings lowering theirs. Even the announcers don't give the benefit of the doubt to 0-4 teams.
Again, no big deal in the scheme of things. We're only talking the difference between 1-15 and 2-14 here, folks. Still, it would have been nice for the guys to have a chance to lose the game on their own, without the nudge from the officials. The way I see it, that bad pass interference call robbed me of discovering Way #564 of how the Lions can lose a football game.
Oh well -- there's always next week.
Wednesday, March 05, 2008
Browns Prove Dumbness Not Relegated To Allen Park
Until today, that was the less-than-flattering nickname given to the city of Cleveland, Ohio. Like many city monikers, it was neither accurate nor fair. Chicago isn't all that Windy, Philadelphia doesn't show much Brotherly Love, and Detroit is losing claim to being the Motor City.
But the new Mistake By The Lake is the Browns' decision to wrap DT Shaun Rogers in green thru the 2013 season, to the tune of $42 million. His current contract was set to expire in 2010; the Brownies added three years and about $20 million to the pot.
That sound you hear is hundreds of thousands of Lions fans clutching their bellies, laughing and pointing across Lake Erie.
"SUCKERS!"
Why the Browns decided to lock Rogers up so quickly, when there was hardly a sense of urgency to do so, is beyond me. They acquired him Friday from the Lions for a draft pick and CB Leigh Bodden.
The Browns, you'd think, would have liked to have seen Rogers squeeze himself into his football pants, at least, before hooking him up with so much dough.
But Rogers is their problem now, so I really shouldn't care. But it's nonetheless amusing to see another team spend its money so foolishly.
There is nothing -- zero, zip, nada -- that makes me think that Rogers will suddenly become a 16-game beast on the D-line, just because he's changed teams. The whole "change of scenery" thing is a nice thought, and I think it's cute that the Browns think that it applies here, but once a scalawag, always a scalawag. The change of scenery theory mostly applies to hard-working but frustrated players who either struggle to find playing time or are caught in a system that doesn't exploit their virtues. It's not designed to be a panacea for all -- especially overweight, out-of-shape, brooding dudes like Shaun Rogers.
Like I've written here, Rogers could have owned Detroit. He could have turned this town on like no other D-lineman since Al "Bubba" Baker -- a modern day Alex Karras, if he had only smiled or talked. After his monster performance against the Broncos in that 44-7 win, Rogers was silent. That was his chance to seize the moment. I would have taken outrageous. I would have taken a Roy Williams-like propensity to say goofy things. I would have taken some humility, some leadership. I would have taken the ability to play more than four plays in a row without needing an oxygen tank.
But none of those things was Shaun Rogers interested in doing, so now he's gone, someone else's concern. The change of scenery theory might apply for a series, a quarter, a game. Maybe even a stretch of several games. But it cannot, I maintain, apply for a 16-game NFL season, because Rogers hasn't shown, in seven years, the gumption to prove otherwise. He's poison, and it's time now to infect another's apple.
The Browns will regret today's decision as early as the midway point of next season. They may even regret it in the first week of training camp, when they look over and see Rogers doubled over, gasping for air.
Friday, February 29, 2008
Lions Need Super Bowl-Winning Management People, Not Players
Damien Woody. Az Hakim. Eric Davis. Dre Bly. Desmond Howard. John Jett. An offensive lineman; a receiver; a couple defensive backs; a kick returner; even a punter, for goodness sake. And there've been more, as you go deeper into history -- players who've won Super Bowls for other organizations, in other years, for other coaches -- who've come to the Lions after having captured The Prize.
They've been looked at with awe in the locker room, for having owned what no other Lions player has come close to sniffing: that elusive World Championship ring.
It's even been a reason, in some instances, why some of those players have been signed to wear the Honolulu Blue and Silver. The old claptrap about how having players on your roster who've won championships somehow services you well. It was mentioned again yesterday, after the Lions signed safety Dwight Smith, proud alumnus of the 2002 Super Bowl-winning Tampa Bay Bucs.
Nonsense!
It's not PLAYERS who've won championships that the Lions have been lacking. Or, to fittingly borrow from an old campaign line in this, an election year: It's the management, stupid.
The Lions have woefully lacked Super Bowl-winning front office types, and that -- way more than a lack of Super Bowl-winning players -- is the biggest reason why they have been ring-less since the Eisenhower administration.
I remember back in the mid-to-late-1990s. Bill Ford Jr. was dispatched by his father to openly spy on the San Francisco 49ers. The objective was to find out how a championship-type organization goes about its business. So the younger Ford hung around the 49ers braintrust for a while, in training camp, taking notes, before reporting back to the brass in Pontiac.
That was over a hundred losses and a half dozen coaches ago.
It's nice to pick the brains of champions, but it's far more effective to go one step further and raid their organizations for their brightest talent.
How many Super Bowl winners do you think the New England Patriots had on their roster before they began their 21st century supremacy? Were the Indy Colts dotted with champions before the current management team took over and built a mini-empire?
As insult to injury, the Super Bowl "winners" that the Lions have signed have often proved to be far from key contributors to their old team's cause, anyhow. Starters? Yeah. Decent players? In some cases. But it's not like the Lions have brought Tom Brady, Marshall Faulk, or Warren Sapp over here, fresh off a championship.
But that's secondary. What's primary is that you cannot model yourself after an elite organization until you are ready to stop admiring from afar and start plundering from within.
The closest the Lions came to doing such a noble thing was in the mid-1980s, when they stole Bears executive Jerry Vainisi. But then they fouled the whole thing up by making him beholden to then-GM Russ Thomas, which completely defeated the purpose. They bought a Rolls Royce and fitted it with an Edsel engine.
So be ready to hear all about Smith and his 2002 experience. About his two returned INTs for touchdowns in the Super Bowl against the Raiders. It's nice. But it was for another team, at another time. You don't win Super Bowls with players resumes. You win with competent front offices and scouts.
The most important Super Bowl-winning talent a team can employ are those who wear suits and ties to work everyday.
Monday, December 10, 2007
Not Surprisingly, Lions Can't Get It Done In Crunch Time
Who among you actually thought Dallas Cowboys QB Tony Romo WASN'T going to lead his team to victory in the final drive of yesterday's game, despite needing 83 yards with 2:15 left and sans timeouts?
Who among you were surprised when Lions linebacker Paris Lenon failed to scoop up a Romo fumble in the final drive?
Who among you actually felt that Jason Hanson's miss of a 35-yard field goal in the final quarter WOULDN'T come back to haunt the Lions?
If anyone raised their hands to any of the previous questions, then you are a candidate for the Liar's Club.
The Lions did it to us again yesterday, waiting till there were 18 seconds left to surrender a lead that they held all afternoon in losing to the Cowboys, 28-27 at Ford Field.
Moral victories have been very familiar to Lions players and fans over the years. Often, the "victory" was in simply surviving without getting blown out. Sunday, the moral victory was almost upsetting the 11-1 Cowboys -- when another blowout seemed very, very possible.
But the ironic thing is that the Lions were in a position to need a REAL victory in December. In the past, a moral victory might have done the franchise some good in this late stage of the season. But it didn't get the Lions from 6-6 to 7-6 yesterday, which they so badly needed to do if they have any hope of making the playoffs.
Ahh, the playoffs. Does it really matter, when you stop to think about it? Would anything be accomplished beyond just extending the season by one more week? Let's play more Liar's Club. Who thinks the Lions would even win a playoff game, anyway? They certainly wouldn't get home field advantage. It would smack of the 1999 season, when they started 8-4, finished 8-8, and got smoked in Washington in the first round.
So it's not really about the playoffs anymore -- at least not in the same way. When the Lions were 6-2, the talk wasn't just about making the playoffs, but of perhaps getting a home game and maybe advancing a round or two. Now, even if by some miracle they win their three remaining games and sneak in at 9-7, winning a postseason game would still be considered a long shot at best.
They can't cover a kickoff -- or a punt -- to save their souls, number one. It's ridiculous how many long returns they've given up this season. More irony here, too, for when the Lions were down in the depths, special teams was one aspect of the team that was relatively strong, all the way around. They had good return men, good kicking and punting, and good coverage. It started all the way back in the Wayne Fontes years with coach Frank Gansz, and continued with Chuck Priefer. The new special teams coach, Stan Kwan, must take some blame here. I don't know what the problem has been, but Kwan may be gone after this season. Kick coverage has been atrocious. Sunday, the Lions were reduced to trying pathetic pooch kicks that they still couldn't cover, giving the Cowboys the same kind of field position as they were getting when the kicks were deep.
"They made one more play than we did," DT Corey Redding said as he walked off the field, speaking to Fox 2's Jennifer Hammond. "We tried our best. But they made one more play than we did."
"They made one more play than we did."
It should be put on the Lions franchise's tombstone.
Friday, November 30, 2007
Despite Hordes Of Losses In Minnesota, Three Wins Stand Out
Perhaps the most memorable was a win in 1974.
The Lions, when they invaded the old Metropolitan Stadium in October '74, hadn't beaten the Vikings since December, 1967. That was 13 straight losses to the Purple People Eaters, who will always be my most hated team in all of sports. And, the Lions were 1-4, which didn't inspire much confidence. Part of the early-season strife could be blamed on the death of head coach Don McCafferty, who died of a heart attack during training camp, while cutting his lawn at home. McCafferty's death thrust assistant Rick Forzano into the top spot. Forzano was a former college coach who'd never been a head coach at the pro level. The latter distinction had never stopped the Lions, of course, from hiring such folks, but McCafferty's untimely passing was an excusable reason for giving the untested Forzano the job.
The Lions managed to nudge ahead of the powerful 5-0 Vikings, 20-16, as the fourth quarter clock wound down. But Minnesota was on the move. It looked like they would, once again, steal a win from the Lions, who during the 0-13 streak had the Vikes on the ropes many times, only to have something weird happen to them.
The Vikings drove down the field, led by Fran Tarkenton. But being down by four, they needed a touchdown. They neared the Lions' 20-yard line.
Tarkenton scrambled and fired a pass in the end zone. There was a collision, and the ball popped gently into the air. But instead of being snagged by a Vikings receiver (which wouldn't have been surprising), the football was cradled by DB Lem Barney. His secondary mates crowded around Barney and forced him to down the ball in the end zone, ensuring the Lions victory. The 0-13 streak was over -- and with the 1-4 Lions beating the 5-0 Vikings!

Barney, who hadn't beaten the Vikings since his rookie season in 1967, before sealing 1974's win in Minnesota with a pick in the end zone
It was so ironic, because many much better Lions teams had outplayed the Vikings in the past yet lost.
Another win in Minnesota that sticks out was in 1991, the Sunday before Thanksgiving. This was the 12-4, Mike Utley year. It wasn't so much the win that stands out as the move that Barry Sanders made on safety Joey Browner that I swore could have blown out both of Browner's knees.
Sanders got into the open field and juked Browner -- who was a pretty darn good player -- so badly that he, at once, both froze Browner and rattled the safety's knees. He reduced a Pro Bowl player to nothing more than an orange construction zone cone. Of course, Sanders also made other great players look silly in similar scenarios, such as Rod Woodson (who really did blow out a knee against Sanders) and John Lynch.
Then there was a 1993 win, in which the Lions trailed 27-23 in the waning seconds on Sunday Night Football. But Rodney Peete drove the Lions downfield and, facing a fourth-and-goal, threw in the direction of Brett Perriman in the end zone. There was contact, but it would have been unsurprising if the officials called nothing, especially on such a crucial play. Yet here comes the flag, to the howls of the Metrodome crowd. Now with first-and-goal at the one, the Lions scored, and stole a 30-27 win just before the final gun.
"Couldn't have happened to a better team," I said of the Vikings.
Sunday, the Lions return to another of their houses of horrors. They need a win in the worst way, and they could have picked a better place to seek it than the awful Metrodome. Strange things happen to them in the state of Minnesota. Always have.