Showing posts with label Rod Marinelli. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rod Marinelli. Show all posts

Friday, January 16, 2009

Schwartz Has More To Offer Than Just A Non-M Last Name

They put another coach in front of the firing squad today in Allen Park.

Jim Schwartz is the latest one to sign his own walking papers. That's what you do, you know, when you sign on to be a head coach in pro sports. The clock starts ticking toward your eventual ziggy before the ink dries on your signature.

But that's just so cynical of me, isn't it?

First impressions of Schwartz, introduced today as the Lions' new head coach: not bad. He sounded confident and relaxed. Like this wasn't his first head coaching job. Like he wasn't stepping into the doo-doo of 0-16 and a dysfunctional front office. Like he's done this sort of thing before.

I didn't get that impression with Schwartz's predecessor, the beleaguered Rod Marinelli. From the get go, although I liked Marinelli's military-like persona, Marinelli spoke like he was, well, doing this for the first time. His speech seemed too contrived, too prepared. I didn't draw the comparison until I heard Schwartz talk, and he was very relaxed and "oh, by the way."

Of course, Schwartz has been a defensive coordinator for some eight years. You'd expect him to be more polished, frankly. And he sure seems to be.

He even got off a crack.

"If I had known it was going to be this cold here, I would have asked for more money," he said as the media types laughed.

Hey, if he knew what he was getting himself into, truly knew, he'd ask for a Brinks Truck.

The Lions must have listened to me, for a change.

I implored them to find someone who comes from a winning pedigree, and at the very least from a coordinator's role. Well, Schwartz would seem to qualify; he learned from Bill Belichick early on, and Jeff Fisher later. He coordinated the Tennessee Titans defense, and did alright. The Titans' defense was consistently among the best in the NFL. So that's good.

It remains to be seen, of course, how Schwartz will react once it sinks in: that he doesn't appear to have as much say-so in personnel matters as many NFL head coaches possess. Also, once it sinks in that tweedle-dee and tweedle-dum, aka Martin Mayhew and Tom Lewand, are really the ones in charge. Hopefully, Schwartz won't become mystified. Check back come draft time.


The Lions' new head coach, Jim Schwartz, in happier days


But for now, it's all about Schwartz hiring a staff and beginning to evaluate what he has in Detroit. It's not much, and he said as much on Monday, when he was propped up before the media as part of his interviewing process. He politely said there were "some holes" in the roster, but was quick to add that many teams have such holes. That wasn't an easy thing to buy.

When the Lions hired Steve Mariucci, some six years ago already, they created a humongous stage on Ford Field's turf and Mooch made the long walk from the tunnel, flanked by Matt Millen and Bill Ford Jr. Even Mariucci himself, once he saw what the Lions had created, spectacle-wise, said simply, "Wow."

Too bad Mooch never lived up to that stage.

This time, Jim Schwartz held a simple, rather brief gathering -- in the same spot where Lions coaches speak to the media every week. His demeanor was casual, belying the gravity of the moment. He talked of his growing up as one of nine kids in Baltimore. Not exactly a hard-scrabble life, but certainly not with a silver spoon in his mouth, either. He said his dad would have been disappointed in him if he didn't take this challenge, because the Schwartzes never shrink from challenges. He talked a little about making his defense all-purpose: able to quell the run and the pass, if need be, based on the opponent. He spoke of becoming big and strong on the football field.

Then, just like that, he was pulled away, after a few innocent questions.

But that's OK. All intro press conferences of coaches are alike, mostly. But I was still taken by Schwartz's casualness, and his lack of awe. He expected to be a head coach someday, and now it's here. 0-16 doesn't faze him. We see a gooey, hideous mess. He simply sees a challenge.

The grass on the Lions' side of the fence never looks as brown and as full of manure as we see it from the inside.

So good luck to Mr. Schwartz. For the record, I'm OK with this.

His last name doesn't begin with M, for one.

It's a start.

Tuesday, December 30, 2008

Marinelli Gets The Ziggy, But Ford Didn't Fire Him

It will be written and recorded that Bill Ford Sr. fired Rod Marinelli. History will be wrong.

Ford didn't fire Marinelli; circumstances did. Ford was merely the vessel, the one who sent out the press release announcing the development, one that even he, with his loyal and kind heart, couldn't stall.

There are so few things you can count on in life anymore: getting stuck in traffic when you're running late; being the one who finishes the toilet paper roll; paying taxes; dying. Oh, and this one: going 0-16 will get you fired.

It wasn't impressive, not at all, that Marinelli got the ziggy yesterday after 0-16 and 1-23 and 10-38. The zenith of his time here was when he was 9-15 after the 6-2 start of 2007 (remember that?). Actually, the zenith of his time here, I believe, was in January 2006 -- when he stood in front of the media throng the day he was announced as head coach.

"Good morning, men," Marinelli famously said that day, as if he was a military general addressing the troops. I loved that opening. And I was fooled, as I've been in the past, that the Lions had finally found the right man to coach.

I liked that Marinelli was a D-line man, and that he appeared to appreciate the work done in the trenches. He seemed like substance over style. Then he went out and hired the run-and-gun Mike Martz to coordinate the offense, and that kind of flew in the face of the substance over style thing.

The last Lions head coach worth a hill of beans was Joe Schmidt, and if he hadn't gotten so disgusted with GM Russ Thomas and quit, Schmidt would have been the coach here for as long as he wanted. He was a former Lions player, maybe among the Top Five in team history, and Ford would have been loyal to him. Sadly, Ford sided with Thomas in the power struggle, and the Lions lost out on the best coach they've had since George Wilson and Buddy Parker.

But that's all in the past. It's all about looking forward, but with Ford in the driver's seat, you don't get a chance to look very far. His myopic thinking and approach has choked this franchise, and what you saw with 0-16 was the culmination of a perfect storm of poor management, bad personnel decisions, and all the bad chickens coming home to roost.

Yesterday, I asked for calm, to see what Ford would do in the Allen Park offices in the wake of 0-16. I had not posted those thoughts for more than a minute when the word came down that the only real move was to can the coach, which was terribly predictable and a cause-and-effect of going winless. Oh, another personnel guy is due to be hired, but he will, apparently, be nothing more than part of a three-headed monster -- two of which are coated with the stench of what's been going on with the Lions since 2001.

Rod Marinelli wasn't ready to be a head coach. As I've said before, there's no crime in that. There's nothing wrong with being a fine position coach. Those are necessary, too. But he was a Matt Millen hire, who made three bad coaching choices. He was infatuated with Marty Mornhinweg after one late-night film session; he didn't do the proper due diligence on Steve Mariucci to see if he would be a good fit here; and he selected Marinelli based on a gut feeling, since the resume wasn't there. So don't blame Coach Rod. HE didn't hire him, after all.

So Millen is gone, but the feeling of euphoria that his ziggying was supposed to bring never really materialized. There's a sort of "out of the frying pan and into the fire" thing going on here. Or, "be careful what you wish for." Folks wanted to roll the dice and take their chances with the canning of Millen. Then as the losses piled up this season, they decided to take their chances with a winless year.

The fans got craps for their trouble and risk.

Happy New Year.

Wednesday, August 27, 2008

Marinelli Should Be Run Out Of Town If Kitna Plays Against Bills

The Lions have one more exhibition game -- against the Bills in Buffalo tomorrow night. If starting quarterback Jon Kitna plays one down, then head coach Rod Marinelli ought to be fired.

Actually, firing him would be too good for him. The coach should be tortured -- forced to watch a Facts of Life marathon, or some other heinous thing. Then we should consider some concrete shoes and a dunk in the Detroit River.

The Lions might not be all that in 2008, but they will finish somewhere south of the equator if Kitna goes down for any length of time. He's no Joe Montana or Johnny Unitas, but he's the best the Lions have, easily, behind center. And his three cameos in the pre-season, against other teams' starters, suggest that he's more than ready to go when the curtain rises for real, September 7 in Atlanta.

So why tempt fate and play Kitna against the Bills? What good can come from such an appearance? But plenty can go wrong.

Let me take you back to 1979. The Lions were coming off a 1978 season where they finished strong, winning six of their last nine games. Leading the charge was former World Football League QB Gary Danielson, from Dearborn Divine Child and Purdue University. Danielson peaked against the Vikings on the final Saturday of the season, throwing and running the Lions to a 45-14 win. Some so-called experts predicted some big things for the Lions in '79.

Then came the final exhibition game, in Baltimore.

Danielson, needlessly appearing in the game, scrambled out of trouble. Only, he didn't quite make it. He went down in a heap after being caught, and mangled his knee. Out for the season -- done, after a meaningless play in a meaningless game. Then, suddenly, the Lions' regular season turned meaningless.

Veteran Joe Reed was elevated to no. 1, but Reed was about as mobile as a telephone pole, and before long he was gone, too, to injury. That left the Lions' offense in the rookie hands of Jeff Komlo. The team finished 2-14, with Danielson on crutches and Reed recuperating. Danielson returned in 1980, and the Lions finished 9-7. It was no coincidence.

Now let me take you to 2003. Final pre-season game. Running back James Stewart, playing for God knows what reason, goes down with a career ending (ultimately) shoulder injury.

The Lions, as usual, have no capable backup quarterback -- no veteran who can step in and run the show. The roster shows Dan Orlovsky, an injured Drew Stanton, and recently signed Drew Henson. The thought of Kitna going down ought to make your skin crawl.

So why there's even any question whether Kitna should suit up and enter the game in Buffalo tomorrow night, is anyone's guess. I don't even want him to trot on the field, only to be called back to the sideline. He may suffer a season-ending toe stub, with the Lions' luck. Certainly bring Kitna along for the plane ride, and let him help out on the sideline, baseball cap and earphone adorning his bald head. But don't let him anywhere near a huddle, unless it's the post-game prayer.

According to the papers, Marinelli hasn't confirmed yet whether Kitna will play tomorrow, nor how much, if he does. Again, there hasn't been a no-brainer this obvious since Moses pondered whether to part the Red Sea.

Yes, it's true that (God forbid) Kitna could go down in the regular season opener. But losing a QB, or any front line player, in a game that counts in the standings is a lot easier to swallow than to lose one in any game played before Labor Day. And yes, Kitna has proven to be durable; he has started all 32 games since he's been a Lion. He's barely missed any playing time due to injury (last year's concussion against the Vikings notwithstanding). Still, only bad things can happen when you play your starting quarterback in the fourth and final pre-season game -- the Mother of All Meaningless Games. The only players who the fourth pre-season game means anything to are those fighting for roster spots. With the trio of quarterbacks below him on the depth chart, Jon Kitna hardly has to wage THAT battle. So don't play him. Not for one down. Don't even let him put his helmet on.

The head coach is no dumb-dumb. He should get that, shouldn't he?

Friday, September 21, 2007

Eagles Didn't Always Soar In The NFL

The emotional football coach, never one to be shy to squeeze a few wet ones from his eyes, stood in the locker room to give his pre-game speech. And his voice quaked as he spoke in halting fashion.

"Twelve years," the coach said, pacing the room, looking at his players. "Twelve years have gone by since the Eagles have come out winners. Well, we're gonna come out winners today.

"We've lost a few we should have won, but guess what? We've won a few we should have lost. We're right where we deserve to be -- playing for the first winning record in Philadelphia since 1966."

Dick Vermeil was perhaps 30 pounds lighter as he delivered that speech in 1978, in full view of the NFL Films cameras. He wore a garish white belt around his checkered polyester trousers, the fashion statement for football coaches back in the day. It was the year of the Miracle in the Meadowlands, when Herman Edwards scooped up a Joe Pisarcik fumble and took it to the house to beat the Giants in the waning moments, when a simple kneel-down would have sealed the deal for New York. That's probably one of the games Vermeil was referrring to. Likely.

The Eagles won that day, the final game of the '78 season, and had themselves a 9-7 record. And Vermeil was right. It was the first winning football record in Philadelphia since the days of Joe Kuharich as coach and Norm Snead at quarterback.


Jaworski wasn't the most talented QB, but his toughness led the Eagles to Super Bowl XV

The Lions haven't gone 12 years since their last above-.500 record. It only seems that way. In fact, a quick trip to the data files shows that in the previous 11 seasons before this one, the Lions have actually managed to have two such winning campaigns -- 1997 and 2000. So the Eagles of 1967-77 were worse in that regard.

It might be hard to imagine now, with a Super Bowl appearance and annual trips to the playoffs in recent years, but the Philadelphia Eagles didn't always soar. Far from it.

The Lions haven't won an NFL championship since 1957. But the Eagles aren't much better. Their last title came in 1960. In fact, the Lions from 1960-75 were a far superior team than the Eagles in that same time frame. But then Philly hired Vermeil from UCLA, and all that changed. The Eagles made Super Bowl XV in 1981. In the quarter century since, the Eagles have fielded competitive teams far more often than they haven't.

The Eagles ended their misery through the coaching sleight of hand of Vermeil and the tough-as-nails quarterbacking of Ron Jaworski. And with a swarming defense.

Lions QB Jon Kitna earned points last Sunday for his body-sacrificing in the OT win over Minnesota. He returned from a mild concussion to lead the team to victory. It had old curmudgeons like me recalling the days of Bobby Layne, mainly because I would defy you to come up with a similar example from a Lions quarterback between 1958, Layne's last year in Detroit, and last Sunday. Coach Rod Marinelli loves the word "tough", and he used it often in describing Kitna's performance.

"That was special," the coach said after the game. "That's toughness right there. He's tough. This is a tough city and it deserves a tough quarterback. And that's what this city has -- a tough quarterback representing it."

Those might have been the words of Dick Vermeil in describing Ron Jaworski, circa 1978.

So if you look at the Eagles, this week's Lions opponent, and think that they've been good forever, hold on. It only seems that way.

Friday, May 18, 2007

Rod Marinelli: A Coach Who Can't Contain Himself

With the Pistons moving on and the Red Wings in a 2-2 standoff with the Anaheim Ducks, I thought this might be a good time to interrupt your regularly scheduled playoff posts and present to you, as a form of light entertainment fare, those wacky Detroit Lions.

Well, maybe not so wacky, if you listen to coach Rod Marinelli.

"I just have great expectations," the Rock Pounder mused yesterday to reporters as the team wrapped up their three-day minicamp. The superlatives rolled off his tongue like an opponent pass rusher off a Lions offensive lineman.

"I just believe in this team -- a lot... This is going to be a very good team...It's what I see. I'm out here, I look, I see it, and I believe it....I've got great expectations for this team. I like the way they're working. You're seeing what I'm seeing. It's fast and explosive."

So when do playoff tickets go on sale?

Now, the fruit salad that Marinelli is excreting doesn't annoy me so much because I get the feeling that if things weren't going so well, we'd hear about that, too. The coach has never struck me as much of a snake oil salesman, like so many of his predecessors. So it's nice, I suppose, to hear about the love-in going on in Allen Park. Heck, there was even a photo the other day of defensive tackle Shaun Rogers SMILING -- laughing, actually -- with Marinelli. And Rogers spoke a bit, too -- quite positively, I might add.

A couple months ago I spoke to QB Jon Kitna over the telephone for a brief Q&A for my former gig, and I asked him to complete this sentence: In 2007, I promise the Detroit Lions fans _______.

He didn't hesitate for long before he filled in the blank.

"In 2007, I promise the Detroit Lions fans that we'll win at least 10 games," Kitna said. I reminded him that this was one of those Q&A's that actually finds its way into print, in front of real, live eyeballs attached to real, live Lions fans.

"That doesn't scare me one bit," Kitna said.

Kitna was one of those who Marinelli praised this week. Must be for his positive outlook, if nothing else.